Would the us have won the revolutionary war without france

From 1776 to 1783 france supplied the united states with millions of livres in cash and credit. I think its very unlikely that the american revolutionary war would have been won without french aid, but i do think the united states would have achieved its. Could the us have won the war of independence without french help. France was looking for any way to boost its own reputation while undermining britains, and helping the. Patriots have won the revolutionary war without the help of france. The french are often portrayed in us history as only being involved in the revolutionary war after the victory at saratoga. A heroine of the revolutionary war, molly pitcher was the nickname of a woman said to have carried water to american soldiers during the battle of monmouth on june 28, 1778, before taking over for. However, what started in 1775, as an american rebellion against british rule in the thirteen colonies evolved into a farreaching global war among worlds most powerful nations. Would the patriots have won the war without help from. When 70yearold benjamin franklin boarded the continental sloopofwar reprisal in philadelphia on october 26, 1776, for a monthlong voyage to france, gen. There is no doubt that america would not have won the revolutionary war without frances financial and military aid and that franklin was almost entirely responsible for obtaining that aid. Without the direct and indirect assistance of france, it is doubtful that americans could have won the war for independence. Let us write or edit the essay on your topic could the us have won the revolutionary war without foreign intervention with a personal 20% discount. It was, ironically, englands victory over france for control of the north american continent in the seven years war 17561763 that laid the basis for their north american colonies to revolt.

How did the alliance with france help the colonies win the. European entanglements derailed any chance the english had of winning the war in north america. Benjamin franklins reception at the court of france in 1776. Could the americans have won the american revolution. Grab the best paper we use cookies to create the best experience for you. I know weve labored the point here, but they werent the same thing. The french revolutionary wars were a series of sweeping military conflicts lasting from 1792 until 1802 and resulting from the french revolution. When 70yearold benjamin franklin boarded the continental sloopof war reprisal in philadelphia on october 26, 1776, for a monthlong voyage to france, gen.

On the continent, france was protected through its alliance with austria which, even if it did not take part in the american revolutionary war, affirmed its diplomatic support of france. There was the war of 1812, the war of 1833, the first ohiovirginia war. Would they have won is a different question because im not sure how much higher a priority they could have placed on the war effort from 17761779. Without their fleet, the yorktown surrender by the british may never had happened.

Three years after the war started, france allied itself with the colonies in 1778, though had been secretly sending supplies for a few years. Why there would be no united states of america without france. Could the us colonies patriots have won the revolutionary war without the help of france. While it was arguably europes most prestigious nation, france had suffered humiliating defeats to the british in the seven years warespecially its american theater, the frenchindian warseveral years earlier. Without the help of foreign nations and especially france, the us would have been crushed. In which john green teaches you about the american revolution. Florida would likely be an independent nation the collapse of the spanish empire was going to happen no matter what.

In 1775, revolutionaries seized control of all the thirteen colonial. Sep 23, 2019 britain quit the american revolutionary war rather than fight another global war with france. The declaration of independence a document that was adopted by the continental congress meeting at philadelphia, pennsylvania on july 4, 1776, which declared that the american colonies were now indepedent from. The assistance by france especially was crucial in putting an end to the war. In formulating your answer, consider that france did not. No, because they had a weak, poorly supplied army with not many men or much money. Most historians would answer that winning independence from great britain without the. France, who had been rebuilding their navy and other forces, saw this as a perfect. With the combined leadership of french general rochambeau and more. Benjamin franklin served as the ambassador to france during the war. Even after the americans won at saratoga, french assistance was, well, french.

No, because they had a weak, poorly supplied army with not. Do you agree or disagree with shelby footes statement, and why or why not. Could we americans have won the american revolution. T he american revolutionary war, also known as the american war of independence, was a war between the kingdom of great britain and thirteen british colonies in north american from 1775 to 1783. Would france and spain, englands ageold enemies, aid american rebels.

How france helped win the american revolution american. There were several other colonial uprisings, against britain and against other colonial powers elsewhere, before and after, and none of them succeded before napoleonic wars brought spain to its knees in europe. Impact of the allies on the war most historians agree that without outside help the colonists likely would not have won the war. The victory at yorktown would not have been possible without the french. The principal foreign recognition received, of course, was from france. No, but securing french aid had always been a political strategy of the rebels.

American revolution and consequently the french revolution have failed. If the french didnt join the us in the revolutionary war. Would slavery have ended sooner if the british won the. Financial approach the rebelling states were in dire financial situations and could not have financed the war effort much longer and especially if france wo. The war cost france deeply, and this gave noailles and his friends the chance to push a revolutionary agenda at home, when the king was forced to summon a parliament, or estatesgeneral, to raise. The french declaration of war on britain in 1778 was tremendously heartening for the patriots. Joint operations at newport, rhode island and savannah, georgia, disappointed both sides. At that time, it was only a group of thirteen colonies with an army that didnt have enough supplies and wasnt trained well.

France had, after all, lost almost all of their colonies in north america after the seven years war or french and indian war so any way they could put a hurt on britain would be good for them. Its a bit like asking if the rebels could win without achieving their strategic goals. If you were a wouldbe revolutionary looking to start a nation. They absolutely would have won, like devildog said, it would have resulted in greater loss of life and the war would have been prolonged. List of wars involving the united states wikipedia. France had the wealth, the guns, the troops and the ships. How the british won the american revolutionary war.

American revolutionary war great britain vs the colonies. Jul 12, 2019 the war began as a colonial rebellion, but it quickly escalated into a global conflict in which the united states and great britain were merely two of many belligerents. Interesting facts about american allies in the revolutionary war. The war was the end result of the political american revolution, where the colonists overthrew british rule. It raises the crucial question of whether america could have won its independence without the aid of france. After the french monarchy was abolished in september 1792, the united states refused to continue repaying its large debt to france, which had supported the u. Americas first ally looks at the contributions of individual french officers and troops, arguing that america could not have won without them. Or at least it was after the unintended battles at lexington and concord neither side wanted war led to a full scale conflict. Somewhere between the real yorktown and mel gibsons rather less accurate version, the patriot, the monumental french war effort during the birth of america got forgotten, buried in the sand, and pissed on the truth is, the colonies would never have earned their freedom without.

France did consider the landing of 40,000 men in the nearby british isles but abandoned the idea because of logistical issues. Would america have won the revolutionary war without. Could the us have won the revolutionary war without. A french expeditionary force arrived in the united states in 1780.

How the british won the american revolutionary war journal. Jan 17, 2009 france was in a war with england at the time of the revolution, and helped us fight the common enemy. Popular support for the revolutionary war was overwhelming. At the start of the war, the colonists didnt have the hard currency needed to field an army due to the currency act which made british silver in the.

This might seem like a triumph for france, but in truth, it was a disaster. At the war s outset, france secretly provided to the. The westward expansion would not have happened without a war with france. Could the us have won the war of independence without. This american victory was a turning point because it destroyed the british hopes of an easy war and lifted the spirits of many patriots. They pitted france against great britain, austria, prussia, russia and several other monarchies. Nov 17, 2015 there would be no united states without france. Without the french, america may have never won the revolutionary war. In the centuries since the revolutionary war, french contributions have been criminally downplayed.

France in the american revolutionary war wikipedia. Ultimately, the americans prevailed due to their spirit and the fact that they were fighting for something they believed in. Eastern north america, gibraltar, india, caribbean sea, and the atlantic. He would use his intellect, charm, wit, and experience to convince france to join the war on. Indeed, the powerful words of the declaration of independence have been used many times since the revolutionary war to challenge racism and other forms of domination and inequality. Desmarais explores the international nature of a war which some people have called the first world war.

With regrads to the american revolutionary war, help from france was necessary. Without france, the entire american revolution would have. The american war of independence was important to the french revolution because the americans would not have won without the help of the french. France s assistance to the americans in their bid for independence cannot over stated. Jul 27, 2015 detail of 1781 portrait of king george iii by thomas gainsborough. It would have to look like the roman social war, where rome was victorious in the field but the defeated italians ended up getting most of what they went to war for. T he american revolutionary war, also known as the american war of independence, was a war between the kingdom of great britain and thirteen british colonies in north american from 1775 to 1783 the war was the end result of the political american revolution, where the colonists overthrew british rule. Jun 27, 2019 americas first ally looks at the contributions of individual french officers and troops, arguing that america could not have won without them. As was demonstrated at the battle of yorktown, the french alliance was. The scots had risen in 1745 and forced the recall of the british army from the continent, with the obvious consequences for britains dutch and german allies. Mar 14, 20 in which john green teaches you about the american revolution. Even without frances guns, ships, supplies, and partnership the americans still could. Could america have won the revolutionary war without.

France and britain drifted into hostilities without a declaration of war when their fleets off ushant off the northwest coast of france on june 17, 1778. How trumps airport gaffe masked a dangerous misunderstanding. Following the declaration of independence, the american revolution was well received by. Manpower alone hardly would have guaranteed victory, indeed it would have made calamitous defeats like. Without allies, britain would have beat them in a wink.

George washington s continental army was losing the american revolutionary war. Could america have won the revolutionary war without french help. Thirteen years earlier, they had been defeated by the british in the french and indian war and, as a result. As soon as the french intervened the americans had 1 up on the british. Who won the american revolution crash course us history. There is no doubt that america would not have won the revolutionary war without france s financial and military aid and that franklin was almost entirely responsible for obtaining that aid. France was in a war with england at the time of the revolution, and helped us fight the common enemy. Part of me even wonders if a compromise in which the continental congress is given home ruleesque powers in exchange for. Could the americans have won the revolutionary war without. Myths of the american revolution history smithsonian magazine. The financial pressures france faced at the time were only made worse by the cost of aiding the americans.

The second, a treaty of alliance, contained several stipulations. The role of france in the american revolutionary war. At the wars outset, france secretly provided to the. Myths of the american revolution history smithsonian. May 15, 2008 they absolutely would have won, like devildog said, it would have resulted in greater loss of life and the war would have been prolonged.

There would be no united states without france mental floss. Could america have won the revolutionary war without french. The battle for new york in 1776 gave england an excellent opportunity for a decisive victory. Would america have won the revolutionary war without france. Both the 1789 french revolution and the 1804 haitian revolutionthe only successful slave revolt in human historydrew inspiration from this clarion call. The simple truth is, you cannot hold on to a rebellious colony of that scale 8000 miles away, across an ocean. The american revolutionary war 17751783, also known as the american war of independence, was fought primarily between the kingdom of great britain and her thirteen colonies in america, resulting in the overthrow of british rule in the colonies and the establishment of the united states of america. Could the colonies have won independence without the. Could the british empire have won the american revolutionary war. The outcome would have not changed due to the intervention of france because that was the turning point of the war to begin with. The american revolution could not have been won so decisively without the significant naval and tactical aid of france. Without the help of spain, the netherlands, and especially france, its unlikely the colonists would have prevailed. America was too vast a territory to hold, and the demographics werent in britains favor.

Quasiguerre was an undeclared war fought almost entirely at sea between the united states and france from 1798 to 1800, which broke out during the beginning of john adamss presidency. I asked turtledove what the world might have looked like in 2014 if britain had won the revolutionary war, or if the war had never been fought in the first place. This is a comprehensive look at how france influenced the american revolutionary war in a variety of ways. A treaty of alliance followed in 1778, which led to french shipments of money and materiel to the united states of america. Most historians would answer that winning independence from great britain without the help of france may have. Of course, the americans won their freedom from british rule. George washingtons continental army was losing the american revolutionary war. Even if youve heard that money or career success wont necessarily make you. Would the patriots would have won the revolutionary war without help from france and spain. France had suffered bitter defeat in the most recent conflict, the seven years war 175663. Could the american colonies have won the war of independence. Would the patriots would have won the revolutionary war. French involvement in the american revolutionary war of 17751783 began in 1775, when. Second, neither france nor america could conclude peace with britain without the consent of the other.

American revolution, french alliance, siege of yorktown. Jul 04, 2017 the westward expansion would not have happened without a war with france. Could the colonies have won independence without the french. First, if france entered the war, neither country would stop fighting until america won its independence. Relations became a little strained towards the end of washingtons presidency, but no, i dont think we could have won without them.

Both the 1789 french revolution and the 1804 haitian revolution the only successful slave revolt in human historydrew inspiration from this clarion call. The american revolutionary war 17751783, also known as the american war of independence, was fought primarily between the kingdom of great britain and her thirteen colonies in america, resulting in the overthrow of british rule in the colonies and the establishment of the united states of america after 1765, growing political differences concerning mounting taxes without. Jul 04, 2014 i asked turtledove what the world might have looked like in 2014 if britain had won the revolutionary war, or if the war had never been fought in the first place. Could we americans have won the american revolution without. Manpower alone hardly would have guaranteed victory, indeed it would have made calamitous defeats like saratoga more disastrous than they were. But the american revolution was a global war, and elsewhere the french. Could the us have won the revolutionary war without foreign. This limited the number of troops avaailable for operations as well as made the revolutionary war in n. America or us colonies or patriots or united states of america these are all different terms for the same thing, all of these are correct answer. French involvement in the american revolutionary war of 17751783 began in 1775, when france, a hotbed of enlightenment liberal ideologies and the archnemesis of the british empire, secretly shipped supplies to the continental army established in june 1775.